Our Leadership Obsession






Try this little experiment. Go to Amazon.com and do an advanced search. First, search for books which have the word "leader" in the title. If you do it soon, you'll see there are 24,668 results. Number one in the list (sorted by relevance) is something about being the "pack leader" in order to transform the life of your dog. After browsing a bit, do another advanced search, this time with the word "follower" in the title. You'll find 865 results, most of them about Christian followers of Jesus (though a few leadership books which happen to have the word "follower" in the title have snuck into our search). For every book about being a follower there are 25 more about being a leader. I don't find Jesus quite so obsessed with leadership as we are. Quite the opposite in fact.


Check this out. Go to Biblegateway.com. Search for how many times Jesus uses the word "lead" in the gospels. You'll find in the NIV there are 21 times, and most of the references are negative! Judas leading the crowds to apprehend Jesus, the blind leading the blind, and so on. None of them are commands to the disciples. Now check out how many times he uses the word, "follow." There are 86 references - four times as many, most of them positive and many of them direct commands ... as in "come follow me." Jesus was far and away more concerned about his disciples ability to follow well than about them leading well.


Why are we so obsessed with leadership? Why is following so disdainful to us? We don't even have the word "followship" in English. Now, to be sure, leadership is a wonderful spiritual gift, one that I think I possess. But how is it that Jesus taught so clearly and thoroughly about following, and I can go to Amazon.com, restricting my search to "religion and spirituality" and still come up with 15 times as many "religious" books about being a good leader as I can about being a good follower?


The American quest for Independence has poisoned us. The leadership obsession within capitalism has infected our spirituality. These influences have convinced us that following is for wimps.

Submission is central to spiritual growth, and following is almost always the more important quality in the kingdom of God than perfecting your leadership gifts. The problem is that books on submitting just don't sell. I'm still waiting for someone to write the book, Extraordinary Submission: Turning Good Leaders into Obedient Followers. I have the feeling it could be a long wait.

New Friars: The Unofficial Guide




When I wrote The New Friars (now two years since the first draft was submitted and a year since the first copy rolled off the press) I was enthralled with the qualities which consistently cropped up in missionizing monastic movements, despite the fact that their origins hearken back to different centuries on different continents within different historic Christian traditions. I worked hard to sift and distill the energizing fundamentals of the Moravians, Jesuits, Franciscans, Celtic monks and the Nestorians, while comparing them with the emerging movement of young, pseudo-friars who today are fanning out into the impoverished places of our world with the same sort of reckless abandon.

I ended up deciding on five radioactive elements which all these movements have in common - namely, that they are enamored with being incarnational, committed to a communal lifestyle and bent on observing highest levels of Christian devotion, all the while doing mission on society's margins. It seemed like these five things pulsed through veins of the ancient missionizing monks and nuns of old, and have begun to bear themselves out in the emerging "orders" of today.

What I did not write about were the quirky things that seemed to consistently show up in the historic orders - little idiosyncrasies that kept coming up up on my radar. Things like their penchant for music ... the Moravians even organized their communities by choirs. Or the fact that each of these movements had powerful tendencies toward mysticism- their members wracked at times by mystical encounters with the divine. All of them had obsessions with scholarship, and, of course, dabbled in asceticism, embracing bizarre extremes of denial of self-flagellation. But the oddest commonality in these movements was an almost morbid interest in the wounds of Christ.

The Moravians would speak and sing about kissing the wounds of Jesus, and several sources confirm the appearance of the stigmata (the nail prints and spear hole) on the body of St. Francis. I'm sure the founders of these historic orders would all have venerated Mel Gibson's, The Passion of the Christ, making it required viewing for their adherents. What is it about the physical mortification of Jesus that so fired their devotional imagination?

Paul speaks in a few places about sharing in the sufferings of Christ (Rom. 8:17, 2 Cor. 1:5, Phil. 3:10) and in at least two passages he seems to speak of a physical connection to Jesus' torture. Colossians 1:24 says, "...I fill up in my flesh what is still lacking in regard to Christ's afflictions, for the sake of his body, which is the church." and in Galatians 6:17, Paul confides that he bears in his body the marks of Jesus.

Now, I am not about to undertake the practice of the Celtic abbess, Ite, who kept a stag-beetle under her clothes to gnaw at her flesh, but I do wonder if in this age of comfort-at-all-costs we miss something of freedom and fearlessness that comes when one is able to bear up under physical pain. Missiologist and Gordon College professor, Paul Borthwick says he doesn't think he'd mind being killed for Christ ... but being tortured and then killed, well, that's another story. Without getting masochistic about it, nor to drift into Buddhist philosophy or asceticism, is there a readiness in our practice of the faith to embrace physical suffering?

Disclaimer: These blogs are the words of the writers and do not represent InterVarsity or Urbana. The same is true of any comments which may be posted about any blog entries. Submitted comments may or may not be posted within the blog, at the bloggers' discretion.

learn. be. go. serve. ask.

 

"Holy, holy, holy is the Lord God Almighty, who was, and is, and is to come!"

Revelation 4:8 (NIV)

 
 

Urbana Stories

“Searching for direction in my life. God spoke to me at Urbana 67 through the spirit filled speakers and Dr....”

read more

share your story

 

Books by Scott Bessenecker:
The New Friars: The Emerging Movement Serving the World's Poor

How to Inherit the Earth - coming in November
coming in November