Plan A, B, C
For you created my inmost being; you knit me together in my mother's womb. I praise you because I am fearfully and wonderfully made; your works are wonderful, I know that full well. - Psalm 139:13-14
The Senate has passed a bill that will approve over-the-counter sales of the "Plan B" pill, also called "the morning after" pill, to women 18 or older; or to younger women with a prescription.
This pill, if taken within 72 hours of unprotected intercourse, is intended to have one of three effects in a woman's body: preventing ovulation or fertilization, or possibly preventing implantation of a fertilized egg on the uterine wall.
In the first two cases the egg would not become fertilized. In the third case, a successfully fertilized egg would be unable to implant itself in the mother's body to become established and grow.
It is estimated by proponents that the availability of this pill could prevent about half of the 3 million unwanted pregnancies in the U.S. each year.
Plan A, which is not available in pharmacies and is often abandoned for convenience or in the heat of the moment, would be for 3 million women and their partners each year to make choices that avoid unwanted pregnancies in the first place. Idealistic, maybe, and this doesn't address cases of rape or incest, but Plan A is really not a bad plan. It's a good plan. Unfortunately, it involves personal discipline and responsibility. And planning (thus the name).
I don't have a strong opinion about Plan B, because in my opinion it's more of a peripheral issue than a core issue. Plan B is misnamed because it's not a plan, in most cases it will probably be used as a response to the consequences of the absence of a responsible plan.
Much of a debate like this one ends up being about semantics, emotions, attitudes of judgement, and entrenched groups who are sworn opponents, duking it out. I'm not discounting the place of morality in this case, nor implying that it's irrelevant.
Making a "morning after" pill more available is not an ideal solution to the problem of unwanted pregnancies, because it also opens the door to new problems. Problems such as making the possibility of casual sexual relationships (at ever younger ages) more convenient, yet with higher (if hidden at first) risks of sexually transmitted diseases including HIV, and higher rates of relational fallout in the long term.
And making this pill less available (or not at all) might be one legal approach, but offers no solution to an issue that really should be addressed at a prior, deeper level. In America, our society on the whole has created a context where young people are enabled and in some ways encouraged by the broader culture to experiment sexually, without responsibility, guidance, planning, appropriate relationships and moral frameworks.
If we made all heavy pointy objects illegal, maybe they would never be used as a weapon to end someone's life. If we made televisions illegal, they would never contribute to the mal-nutrition of healthy families or the negative influences that lead to serious real-world problems.
But far better than officially banning heavy pointy objects or televisions (or even banning "sin") is for people after God's heart, in trusting relationships, to influence the places where these unwanted outcomes get their start - in the heart, mind, body and soul of each one of us.
While I do want our state and federal governments to exercise wise leadership and pass good laws, I also think that there are more important prior places where we who follow Jesus should focus our energy when it comes to encouraging moral, safe, healthy choices and behaviors.
I'm not particularly for or against Plan B.
I am for the sanctity of every human life created by God, and for the (finite, fragile, fallen individuals who make up the) Body of Christ to be salt and light in our world. This should be our main focus, more than external methods that amount to padlocks or bandaids.
I'm in favor of learning how to radically imitate the love of Jesus, not concentrating on laws and rules, which is not a Christlike approach to influencing the world around us.
And if we believe life starts at conception, we should remember it also continues after birth. There are so many places where the value of each human life needs to be protected and honored throughout each person's lifetime. This has to do not only with laws about certain pills and surgeries, but with justice, empowerment, dignity, meeting basic human needs, and living out agape love just like Jesus modeled throughout his life.
Having the mind (spirit) of Christ - maybe we could call this "Plan C."
Spiritually alive, we have access to everything God's Spirit is doing, and can't be judged by unspiritual critics. Isaiah's question, "Is there anyone around who knows God's Spirit, anyone who knows what he is doing?" has been answered: Christ knows, and we have Christ's Spirit. - I Cor. 2:18 (MSG)


